Note that safe mode is largely useless. Most ISPs that offer Perl also offer other scripting languages (mostly Perl), and these other languages don't have the equivalent of PHP.
In other words, if PHP's safe mode won't allow vandals into your web presence, they will simply use Perl.
Also, safe mode prevents scripts from creating and using directories (because they will be owned by the WWW server, not by the user who uploaded the PHP script). So it's not only useless, it's also a hindrance.
The only realistic option is to bugger the Apache folks until they run all scripts as the user who's responsible for a given virtualhost or directory.
안전 모드
Table of Contents
PHP 안전 모드는 공유-서버 보안 문제를 풀려는 시도이다. 이 문제를 PHP 수준에서 풀려고 하는것은 구조적으로 올바르지 않다. 그러나 웹서버와 OS 수준에서의 차선책이 아주 현실적이지는 않기 때문에, 많은 사람, 특히 ISP, 들이 현재 안전 모드를 사용한다.
Warning
안전 모드는 PHP 6.0.0에서 제거되었습니다.
add a note
User Contributed Notes 14 notes
jo at durchholz dot org ¶
19 years ago
gtg782a at mail dot gatech dot edu ¶
21 years ago
zebz: The user would not be able to create a directory outside the namespace where he/she would be able to modify its contents. One can't create a directory that becomes apache-owned unless one owns the parent directory.
Another security risk: since files created by apache are owned by apache, a user could call the fputs function and output PHP code to a newly-created file with a .php extension, thus creating an apache-owned PHP script on the server. Executing that apache-owned script would allow the script to work with files in the apache user's namespace, such as logs. A solution would be to force PHP-created files to be owned by the same owner/group as the script that created them. Using open_basedir would be a likely workaround to prevent ascension into uncontrolled areas.
info at phpcoding dot net ¶
21 years ago
readfile() seems not always to take care of the safe_mode setting.
When the file you want to read with readfile() resides in the same directory as the script itself, it doesn`t matter who the owner of the file is, readfile() will work.
jedi at tstonramp dot com ¶
23 years ago
Many filesystem-related functions are not appropriately restricted when Safe Mode is activated on an NT server it seems. I would assume that this is due to the filesystem not making use of UID.
In all of my scripts, no matter WHO owns the script (file Ownership-wise) or WHO owns the directory/file in question; both UIDs display
(getmyuid() and fileowner()) as UID = 0
This has the rather nasty side effect of Safe Mode allowing multiple filesystem operations because it believes the script owner and file/dir owner are one and the same.
While this can be worked around by the judicious application of proper filesystem privileges, it's still a "dud" that many of Safe Mode's securities are simply not there with an NT implementation.
Anonymous ¶
18 years ago
Each IIS server in Windows runs as a User so it does have a UID file ACLs can be applied via a Group (GID) or User. The trick is to configure each website to run as a distinct user instead of the default of System.
zebz at ihaveenoughspam_hotmail dot com ¶
22 years ago
All the filesystem-related functions (unlink, fopen, unlink, etc) seems to be restricted the same way in safe mode, at least on PHP 4.2. If the file UID is different *but* the directory (where the file is located) UID is the same, it will work.
So creating a directory in safe mode is usually a bad idea since the UID will be different from the script (it will be the apache UID) so it won't be possible to do anything with the files created on this directory.
martin at example dot com ¶
19 years ago
On the note of php security
have a look at: http://www.suphp.org/Home.html
suPHP is a tool for executing PHP scripts with the permissions of their owners. It consists of an Apache module (mod_suphp) and a setuid root binary (suphp) that is called by the Apache module to change the uid of the process executing the PHP interpreter.
Russ ¶
20 years ago
Sometimes you're stuck on a system you don't run and you can't control the setting of safe mode. If your script needs to run on different hosts (some with safe mode, some without it), you can code around it with something like:
<?php
// Check for safe mode
if( ini_get('safe_mode') ){
// Do it the safe mode way
}else{
// Do it the regular way
}
?>
bertrand dot gorge at epistema dot com ¶
20 years ago
Beware that when in safe mode, mkdir creates folders with apache's UID, though the files you create in them are of your script's UID (usually the same as your FTP uid).
What this means is that if you create a folder, you won't be able to remove it, nor to remove any of the files you've created in it (because those operations require the UID to be the same).
Ideally mkdir should create the folder with the script's UID, but this has already been discussed and will not be fixed in the near future.
In the meantime, I would advice NOT to user mkdir in safe mode, as you may end up with folders you can't remove/use.
devik at cdi dot cz ¶
22 years ago
Just to note, I created patch which allows VirtualHost to set User under which all (PHP too) runs. It is more secure than safe_mode. See luxik.cdi.cz/~devik/apache/ if you are interested
Anonymous ¶
19 years ago
To separate distinct open_basedir use : instead of on , or ; on unix machines.
bsd912 at 163 dot com ¶
6 years ago
When in safe mode, mkdir creates folders with apache's UID, though the files you create in them are of your script's UID (usually the same as your FTP uid).
What this means is that if you create a folder, you won't be able to remove it, nor to remove any of the files you've created in it (because those operations require the UID to be the same).
Ideally mkdir should create the folder with the script's UID, but this has already been discussed and will not be fixed in the near future.
And my solution to fix this problem is:
1. You need append the apache group to your script's UID.
2. Turn on safe_mode_gid in the php.ini
3. Chgrp the script to apache, but don't change the UID
4. Now you can use safe_mode and mkdir now.
plyrvt at mail dot ru ¶
19 years ago
[In reply to jedi at tstonramp dot com]
Safe mode is used "since the alternatives at the web server and OS levels aren't very realistic". Manual says about UNIX OS level and UNIX web-servers by design (Apache). It's not realistic for unix-like server, but for NT (IIS) each virtual host can run from different user account, so there is no need in Safe Mode restrictions at all, if proper NTFS rights are set.
daniel dot gaddis at tlc dot state dot tx dot us ¶
20 years ago
on windows if multiple directories are wanted for safe_mode_exec_dir and open_basedir be sure to separate the paths with a semi colon and double quote the whole path string. For example:
safe_mode = On
safe_mode_exec_dir = "F:\WWW\HTML;F:\batfiles\batch"
open_basedir = "F:\WWW\HTML;F:\batfiles\batch"
